+- SG Talk (https://sgtalk.net)
+-- Forum: SG Talk (https://sgtalk.net/Forum-SG-Talk)
+--- Forum: Market Talk (https://sgtalk.net/Forum-Market-Talk)
+--- Thread: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? (/Thread-on-what-basis-china-always-says-taiwan-is-a-part-of-it-cant-be-separated)
on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - talky - 15-01-2024
during the ching dynasty in a treaty ceasefire agreement taiwan was given away to japan after a losing war.
japan ruled twn for ard 50yrs
then japan lost the 2nd ww2 n so taiwan was free from japanese occupation
anyway communist china has never 1 day ruled taiwan
on the contrary kmt ruled china before mao came to power
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - Niubee - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:12 PM)talky Wrote: during the ching dynasty in a treaty ceasefire agreement taiwan was given away to japan after a losing war.
japan ruled twn for ard 50yrs
then japan lost the 2nd ww2 n so taiwan was free from japanese occupation
anyway communist china has never 1 day ruled taiwan
on the contrary kmt ruled china before mao came to power
So the world must believed your monkey story?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - webinarian - 15-01-2024
If you, ts, never read history, you also can Google to read it lah.
.
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - Sticw - 15-01-2024
Chances are the CCP deem they won the war against kmt. Since kmt ran away from mainland and took root in Taiwan island, the natural conclusion for them is Taiwan is part of China.
If kmt deem that the war is not over, CCP will move in to occupy Taiwan. If kmt agrees that they lost to CCP for the right to rule China, then Taiwan is part of China and CCP who is the current overlord of China is the govt...
Anyways, got nothing to do with Singapore..so we better not get involved.
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - WhatDoYouThink! - 15-01-2024
If yr parent's belongings kena stolen, you hv no right to get them back, because you'd never possessed them for 1 day?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - cheekopekman - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:12 PM)talky Wrote: during the ching dynasty in a treaty ceasefire agreement taiwan was given away to japan after a losing war.
japan ruled twn for ard 50yrs
then japan lost the 2nd ww2 n so taiwan was free from japanese occupation
anyway communist china has never 1 day ruled taiwan
on the contrary kmt ruled china before mao came to power
Agreed with you lah!
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - cheekopekman - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:37 PM)Sticw Wrote: Chances are the CCP deem they won the war against kmt. Since kmt ran away from mainland and took root in Taiwan island, the natural conclusion for them is Taiwan is part of China.
If kmt deem that the war is not over, CCP will move in to occupy Taiwan. If kmt agrees that they lost to CCP for the right to rule China, then Taiwan is part of China and CCP who is the current overlord of China is the govt...
Anyways, got nothing to do with Singapore..so we better not get involved.
Taiwan is an independent country not related to China lah!
I say one lah!
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - talky - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:48 PM)cheekopekman Wrote: Agreed with you lah!
after ww2 ended japan rtn taiwan to china which at that time was still ruled by kmt
ccp only came in in 1949
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - webinarian - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:49 PM)cheekopekman Wrote: Taiwan is an independent country not related to China lah!.
If Taiwan is independent, why not a member of UN?
.
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - cheekopekman - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 04:13 PM)webinarian Wrote: .
If Taiwan is independent, why not a member of UN?
.
You ask me how I know leh?
Ask them lah!
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - grotesqueness - 15-01-2024
those chiw cheese pie (ccp) are bullies
taiwan return back to kmt not ccp
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - Omnipresent88 - 15-01-2024
https://youtu.be/GfH4ydvJ8zA?si=82x-2rC4IvWDGX5K
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - WhatDoYouThink! - 15-01-2024
Aiya china can say anything it wants, no need to explain anything to kujinkuraj, right?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - gordongekko - 15-01-2024
all because Jap, Kimchi and Taiwan went ya ya and said this is part of first Island chain and want to contain a big country. If they don't break the chain they will be forever contained in the Island chain named by US and major allies.
If Jap, Kimchi and Tw don't ya ya, sure their neighbor will be living peacefully ever after.
Because of this, they said they also have 9 dash line claim, when they have enough fire power, then we can test each other out see who's claim is more valid. So yes, historically is waste of time but ppl want to instigate you, what you want to do? they stake their claim first until one fine day, they will test it out.
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - cheekopekman - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 05:24 PM)WhatDoYouThink! Wrote: Aiya china can say anything it wants, no need to explain anything to kujinkuraj, right?
China and Taiwan let them settle themselves lah!
Why kaypoh leh?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - winbig - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:57 PM)talky Wrote: after ww2 ended japan rtn taiwan to china which at that time was still ruled by kmt
ccp only came in in 1949
If Japan return Taiwan to China, the means Taiwan is part of China
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - WhatDoYouThink! - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 05:44 PM)cheekopekman Wrote: China and Taiwan let them settle themselves lah!
Yalo. You expect xjp to call you everyday, to explain and seek yr permission meh?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - Niubee - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:57 PM)talky Wrote: after ww2 ended japan rtn taiwan to china which at that time was still ruled by kmt
ccp only came in in 1949
In case u want facts, please read Taiwan Constitution on Taiwan ever an independent country and part of China
Liar like u will interpret anyhow you want like Angmos
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - cheekopekman - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 05:49 PM)WhatDoYouThink! Wrote: Yalo. You expect xjp to call you everyday, to explain and seek yr permission meh?
Must he tell you what he will do leh?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - cityhantam - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:12 PM)talky Wrote: during the ching dynasty in a treaty ceasefire agreement taiwan was given away to japan after a losing war.
japan ruled twn for ard 50yrs
then japan lost the 2nd ww2 n so taiwan was free from japanese occupation
anyway communist china has never 1 day ruled taiwan
on the contrary kmt ruled china before mao came to power
That treaty signed by official of Qing Dynasty is not recognised by winning nations of WW2.
In Taiwan's constitution, which is constitution of Republic of China, Taiwan is a province of China.
China is China, regardless of the dynasty.
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - WhatDoYouThink! - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 06:15 PM)cheekopekman Wrote: Must he tell you what he will do leh?
They'd learned many things from us, must show us respect lah, you dun think so meh
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - talky - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 06:02 PM)Niubee Wrote: In case u want facts, please read Taiwan Constitution on Taiwan ever an independent country and part of China
Liar like u will interpret anyhow you want like Angmos
THE ABOVE IS ALSO A FACT
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - cheekopekman - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 06:39 PM)WhatDoYouThink! Wrote: They'd learned many things from us, must show us respect lah, you dun think so meh
They see us no up why must respect us leh?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - Niubee - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 06:55 PM)talky Wrote: THE ABOVE IS ALSO A FACT
Your fact doesn't mean it is independent country. Geddit ?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - Clyde - 15-01-2024
It is like saying if one day opposition win the election and rule Singapore, Sentosa island can be given away because opposition has never 1 day ruled Sentosa.
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - Niubee - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 08:58 PM)Clyde Wrote: It is like saying if one day opposition win the election and rule Singapore, Sentosa island can be given away because opposition has never 1 day ruled Sentosa.
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - watchfirst9 - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 03:57 PM)talky Wrote: after ww2 ended japan rtn taiwan to china which at that time was still ruled by kmt
ccp only came in in 1949
I can see you never read Jap emperor surrender statement and documents
It is return to China by Laws.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ju-KSn9Ozo
The fact Jap write its surrender and return to is to China, never said it must be ROC.
So whoever is the govt of Chn, own Tw islands.
Tw is never out of UN, as internationally always put remain part of Chn.
Anyway those Twese deny their roots is rather disgusting, their actions similar culture revolution in mid 60s- mid 70s.
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - WhatDoYouThink! - 15-01-2024
(15-01-2024, 07:05 PM)cheekopekman Wrote: They see us no up why must respect us leh?
Waleneh, when ppl look down on you, there're many things you can do.
1. Ignore them
2. Scold them
3. Look down on them aso
4. Ask why then do the above
Other than that, what else can you do?
RE: on what basis china always says taiwan is a part of it cant be separated ? - aiptasia - 16-01-2024
Taiwan is part of China end of.