+- SG Talk (https://sgtalk.net)
+-- Forum: SG Talk (https://sgtalk.net/Forum-SG-Talk)
+--- Forum: Market Talk (https://sgtalk.net/Forum-Market-Talk)
+--- Thread: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined (/Thread-Hawkers-who-do-not-participate-in-free-meal-scheme-will-be-penalised-and-fined)
Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/bukit-canberra-hawker-centres-lease-hawkers-who-do-not-participate-in-free-meal-scheme-will-be-penalised-and-fined.7150601/
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
https://www.zaobao.com.sg/news/singapore/story20250813-7350378
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - Migrant - 14-08-2025
It starts with good intentions.
But along the way....
You sure have many problems.
Saw the SG 60 free ice cream 'queue' .
Long Q with many well dressed young ones under the sun.
Is that for the thrill ?
Or you really need that free ice cream despite the inconveniences?
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
It must also mandate in the contract that taxi drivers and grab drivers to provide free rides to the poor people.
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
all food delivery riders must also provide free delivery to the poor people
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
all GP and dental clinics must also provide free clinics to the poor people
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
all barber shops must provide free hair cut to the poor people
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
all tuition centres must provide free tuition to the poor people
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
all confectionery and bread shops must provide free breads to the poor people
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
all supermarkets must provide free grocery to the poor people
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
all fashion shops must provide free clothing to the poor people
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - RiseofAsia - 14-08-2025
Even the poor also need to pay GST lah.
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - Bigiron - 14-08-2025
根据武吉坎贝拉小贩中心的租约，摊贩如果不参与中心的免费餐食计划，可被记分和须缴付罚金，而不是他们先前所理解的不会有处分。 https://zb.sg/DSk7
1. 澄清
- 具体哪些合约条款规定必须参与免费餐计划？
- “记分”和“罚款”的判定标准是什么？由谁来执行？
- 摊贩最初被告知“没有处分”，那是基于什么沟通或文件？
2. 挖掘假设
- 管理方假设摊贩有能力负担免费餐的成本，这一假设可否成立?
- 设立这种“爱心餐”条款，背后假设所有摊贩都愿意参与公益吗？
- 管理方认为慈善行为应该由合约规范，而不是自发行动，这一做法合理吗？
3. 追问理由与证据
- 管理方为何认为必须用惩罚来保障公益项目实施？有没有成功的自愿参与案例作对照？
- 有没有数据或实际案例表明强制性免费餐条款提升了社区福祉？
- 如果摊贩经济确有压力，有无证据显示该条款导致实际负担加重？
4. 探索影响和后果
- 长远看，这样的惩罚机制会对摊贩行业生态、心理状态产生什么影响？
- 对公众而言，知道“爱心餐”来自强制条款，是否会改变对摊贩或管理方的观感？
- 如果未来所有小贩中心都照此执行，会带来哪些社会影响？
5. 不同视角
- 摊贩如何看待“被规定去做慈善”这件事？有无不同身份（新手/老摊贩/低收入/高收入）的不同看法？
- 消费者和受助者如何看待：被帮助的还是被系统化“分配”这份好意？
- 有没有其他城市、国家采用过自愿VS强制的免费餐制度？效果如何？
6. 反思核心问题
- 这项规定的最终目标是什么？是市场管理，社会公益，还是公共形象？
- 如果不设置“处罚”，摊贩群体会自主承担公益责任吗？如何激励?
- 我们为何关注“免费餐处罚”，真正的问题点是在“强制慈善”，还是管理的透明度？
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - cheekopekman - 14-08-2025
(14-08-2025, 11:07 AM)forum456 Wrote: https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/bukit-canberra-hawker-centres-lease-hawkers-who-do-not-participate-in-free-meal-scheme-will-be-penalised-and-fined.7150601/
They must close shop and not allowed to sell food anymore lah!
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - Migrant - 14-08-2025
Charity must come from the heart.
Not by rules and regulations.
How to differentiate who are the real needy?
I recalled one veg stall used to give out free bee Hoon on 1st and 15th of the month .
But not many takers.
Those who can afford prefers to pay.
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - cityhantam - 14-08-2025
(14-08-2025, 11:29 AM)forum456 Wrote: It must also mandate in the contract that taxi drivers and grab drivers to provide free rides to the poor people.
Can give me free condo and........ free condoms?
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - Migrant - 14-08-2025
Govn can encourage the hawkers to do charity.
But not under written contract.
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - cheekopekman - 14-08-2025
(14-08-2025, 12:44 PM)Migrant Wrote: Govn can encourage the hawkers to do charity.
But not under written contract.
NEA can take away their licences and stalls by force lah!
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - forum456 - 14-08-2025
in the MP contract, all MPs must provide free meals to poor residents
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - Ola - 14-08-2025
Good intentions 一个屁 ！
Forcing people to do Charity Work stated in the Contract
so legally, hawkers can be sued until pants drop
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - cheekopekman - 14-08-2025
(14-08-2025, 02:01 PM)Ola Wrote: Good intentions 一个屁 ！
Forcing people to do Charity Work stated in the Contract
so legally, hawkers can be sued until pants drop
How can force people to do charity leh?
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - Alice Alicia - 14-08-2025
Pap should just get sengsiong and NTUC to open free meal stalls at all hawker centres.
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - Wy:Nox - 14-08-2025
Before I confuse others and myself with this topic- Did MP Ong thinks that he is above the Law and can wash off the ink in the Contract with MP Grace? Let me guess, he had a wonderful private dinner with the Mgmt Operator?
RE: Hawkers who do not participate in free meal scheme will be penalised and fined - cheekopekman - 14-08-2025
(14-08-2025, 08:05 PM)Wy:Nox Wrote: Before I confuse others and myself with this topic- Did MP Ong thinks that he is above the Law and can wash off the ink in the Contract with MP Grace? Let me guess, he had a wonderful private dinner with the Mgmt Operator?
Ong Ye Kung is MP of Sembawang lah!
In case you forgot lah!