Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
sgbuffett - 08-11-2022
She says it is not meaningful. Oh come on, release the breakdown then we will see if it is meaningful.
Why do we need to endure this from a govt that claims it is transparent but insist on hiding information for 50yrs.
https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/pritam-indranee-spar-over-development-costs-of-hdb-flats-details-of-subsidies-to-buyers?utm_campaign=stfb&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&fbclid=IwAR2aeRErubPDv2YuToF-IYCEVA7s5nmZfradHXDv240EPq_qg-B4fWzhpWw
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Gemstar - 08-11-2022
All the unwarranted and rubbish excuses. Very unprofessional trying to sneak her way out. Really making a laughing stock for all to see. This shows their end is near.
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
p1acebo - 08-11-2022
This is the answer given by her civil service minions so she has to toe the line. You donch know how PQs are prepared and answered meh?
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
talky - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 07:29 AM)sgbuffett Wrote: She says it is not meaningful. Oh come on, release the breakdown then we will see if it is meaningful.
Why do we need to endure this from a govt that claims it is transparent but insist on hiding information for 50yrs.
https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/pritam-indranee-spar-over-development-costs-of-hdb-flats-details-of-subsidies-to-buyers?utm_campaign=stfb&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&fbclid=IwAR2aeRErubPDv2YuToF-IYCEVA7s5nmZfradHXDv240EPq_qg-B4fWzhpWw
only opp party members can ask q this in parliament
we commers cant even hv a chance to do so
even then there is no reply
so u see need to hv more opp mps or not ???
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
ODA TETSURO - 08-11-2022
Either she dunno or she dun want to expose her master and let down late LKY...
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
jus4lucky - 08-11-2022
If revealed the cost, citizen know we have been taken for a ride all these years. We are being fool by them since, how to revealed.
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Niubee - 08-11-2022
A normal 4 room flat HDB is no more than 50k per unit. Confirmed by HDB contractor.
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Rainforest - 08-11-2022
Not sure why we need millionaire minister for in the first place to answer this way. Just ask 10x cheaper salaried spoke person to answer the same way will do, i am sure alot forum-mer here can answer this way too. Then it's acceptable for taxpayers. This is the very reason we need more oppies for checks and balances
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
winbig - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 09:05 AM)FartSunKing Wrote: If you not a stupid fcuk
You will be able to estimate the subsidies for a BTO flat
I know the answer to Pritam Singh's question
Simply by looking at the market value of land from GLS
And the psf development cost estimated for HDB flats
Estimate is just guessing. Better to get the actual figure from the govt
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
fishbuff - 08-11-2022
can use such a tactic for my income tax next time. "oh I can't give you the breakdown on my claims but it is a big ballpark figure!"
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Ola - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 09:05 AM)FartSunKing Wrote: If you not a stupid fcuk
You will be able to estimate the subsidies for a BTO flat
I know the answer to Pritam Singh's question
Simply by looking at the market value of land from GLS
And the psf development cost estimated for HDB flats
HELLO Empty Vessel from Malaysia
The question is about the Development COST
not about subsidies that everybody knows and read in the website
How stupid can you be all the time??
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
K88 shu shu - 08-11-2022
when did the PAP govt ever tell peasants the true ?
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
forum456 - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 07:29 AM)sgbuffett Wrote: She says it is not meaningful. Oh come on, release the breakdown then we will see if it is meaningful.
Why do we need to endure this from a govt that claims it is transparent but insist on hiding information for 50yrs.
All past,current and future PAP MPs will never ask this question.
That is why we need more opposition MPs to ask such questions.
If SDP Dr Chee was in parliament, this question would have been asked at least 20 years ago.
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
A2Z - 08-11-2022
Ministers come and go why should HDB Corporation let anyone know?
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Gstalk - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 10:03 AM)forum456 Wrote: All past,current and future PAP MPs will never ask this question.
That is why we need more opposition MPs to ask such questions.
If SDP Dr Chee was in parliament, this question would have been asked at least 20 years ago.
Either she dont know the answer, or at worst she pretend she didn’t hear the questions asked
WTF
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Gstalk - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 09:23 AM)K88 shu shu Wrote: when did the PAP govt ever tell peasants the true ?
They will twist and turn until the questions answer itself?
WTF
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Lukongsimi - 08-11-2022
Quote:hdb flats too hot selling or else she will not say otherwise
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
jus4lucky - 08-11-2022
Even they twist and turn, people also vote for them, why.they tell the truth. Only fool belief them and let them control our lives.
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
talky - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 08:41 AM)Niubee Wrote: A normal 4 room flat HDB is no more than 50k per unit. Confirmed by HDB contractor.
ALL SUFFERED IN SILENCES
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Niubee - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 02:01 PM)talky Wrote: ALL SUFFERED IN SILENCES
SG property are artificially pushed up using these pricing.
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
dynamite - 08-11-2022
Pritam 的口才不错
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
singlon - 08-11-2022
SGD as a currency and money continue to strengthen
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
singlon - 08-11-2022
we need answer
spike proteins poison our people?
so far one two or 3 people died
no see drop 90deg DEAD
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Bigiron - 08-11-2022
andre breton poems
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Symmetry - 08-11-2022
Singapore's Parliament has no standards. Either PaP Ministers just read scripts like radio DJ or cannot answer anything they do in their own job. Seriously, are they working or sleeping on the job?
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Oasis - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 08:41 AM)Niubee Wrote: A normal 4 room flat HDB is no more than 50k per unit. Confirmed by HDB contractor.
Why HDB said flats are heavily subsided and running millions dollars each year?
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Niubee - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 06:34 PM)Oasis Wrote: Why HDB said flats are heavily subsided and running millions dollars each year?
They are doing as business. You overpaid and they will use the profit to subsidize you yr lifetime whatever benefits... my guess. They don't have to go thru other means to subsidize you and family.
Our Govt are smart. They will keep propagate the falsehood of subsidized HDB thinking you benefit from their flat policies. Of course the high price flat has other benefits which is to raise all properties prices public or private in SG. Political wise, these policies help them secure votes etc.
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Niubee - 08-11-2022
(08-11-2022, 06:59 PM)Niubee Wrote: They are doing as business. You overpaid and they will use the profit to subsidize you yr lifetime whatever benefits... my guess. They don't have to go thru other means to subsidize you and family.
Our Govt are smart. They will keep propagate the falsehood of subsidized HDB thinking you benefit from their flat policies. Of course the high price flat has other benefits which is to raise all properties prices public or private in SG. Political wise, these policies help them secure votes etc.
If we were to see the pricing of HDB as per unit and making profits say 200% net profit for Govt.
NONE of our HDBs be it 4rm or 5rm would cost more than $150K considering Govt has made abt 200% profit.
We dont look into your future subsidies or whatever benefits to provide for you people into the HDB pricing.
But if they were to price is $150-200K for those 4-5rm HDB, all the EC and Pte condos will not give current day valuations.
These "growth" help the people to see Pappy contribution to the economy...
![Big Grin Big Grin](https://sgtalk.net/images/smilies/biggrin.png)
And of course, keep voting them.
RE: Minister Indranee refuses to give HDB cost breakdown... -
Sentinel - 08-11-2022
If you drink from the same well, u will not poison it
Common sense
This is PAP's achilles heel
It is the same for WP, SPP, what P..
So who can cut through this?
Only a Chinese can
Dun expect a Malay, Singh or Indian
It's in the DNA
The Chinese has a certain DNA that has the capability of poisoning the well that they drink from
All this is written in the Book of Life
Either you take that red pill or continue with the blue
The truth shall set you free
Blood will be shed
Not nec'ly yours, but those of your loved ones
Be prepared, you have been enlightened
Nothing will remain the same anymore
It is written
Resistance is futile