if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Printable Version
+- SG Talk (https://sgtalk.net)
+-- Forum: SG Talk (https://sgtalk.net/Forum-SG-Talk)
+--- Forum: Market Talk (https://sgtalk.net/Forum-Market-Talk)
+--- Thread: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn (/Thread-if-u-transfer-cpf-oa-to-sa-the-amount-interest-cannot-be-withdrawn)
+- SG Talk (https://sgtalk.net)
+-- Forum: SG Talk (https://sgtalk.net/Forum-SG-Talk)
+--- Forum: Market Talk (https://sgtalk.net/Forum-Market-Talk)
+--- Thread: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn (/Thread-if-u-transfer-cpf-oa-to-sa-the-amount-interest-cannot-be-withdrawn)
Pages:
1
2
if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
that why i didn't transfer my oa to sa.
if u transfer $100k and earn $10k interest.
even if u have reach frs at 55 yrs old and left $120k in sa.
u can only withdraw $10k.
the only way u can withdraw the remaining $110k is when u die, your children can take.
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
https://www.cpf.gov.sg/member/faq/retirement-income/retirement-withdrawals/how-is-the-withdrawable-amount-computed
* Excluding interest earned, any government grants received and top-ups made under the Retirement Sum Topping-up Scheme.
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
https://www.cpf.gov.sg/member/faq/growing-your-savings/retirement-sum-topping-up-scheme/how-much-cpf-savings-can-i-transfer-to-myself-or-my-loved-ones-
transfer from oa to sa is part of Retirement Sum Topping-Up Scheme
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Goldmine - 09-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:19 PM)uncle168 Wrote: that why i didn't transfer my oa to sa.
if u transfer $100k and earn $10k interest.
even if u have reach frs at 55 yrs old and left $120k in sa.
u can only withdraw $10k.
the only way u can withdraw the remaining $110k is when u die, your children can take.
keekeekee
Can lah!
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
u withdrawn b4?
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Goldmine - 09-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:32 PM)uncle168 Wrote: u withdrawn be?
Nothing left in my special account for scammer to scam.
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
i posted the cpf links, it say cannot lah.
or everybody would have transfer oa to sa loh
cpf keep quiet or nobody will transfer
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
the cpf top up scam is to help u reach frs not for u to cash out ok.
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Goldmine - 09-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:34 PM)uncle168 Wrote: i posted the cpf links, it say cannot lah.
or everybody would have transfer oa to sa loh
cpf keep quiet or nobody will transfer
keekeekee
When you reached 55, u can withdraw all balances in yr O/A and S/A provided your FRS is met.
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
u can withdraw everything?
are u sure?
the cpf website even gave an example cannot leh
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - winbig - 09-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:19 PM)uncle168 Wrote: that why i didn't transfer my oa to sa.
if u transfer $100k and earn $10k interest.
even if u have reach frs at 55 yrs old and left $120k in sa.
u can only withdraw $10k.
the only way u can withdraw the remaining $110k is when u die, your children can take.
keekeekee
Move money from OA to SA is to earn more interest rate. If u compound your CPF at a higher interest, in future, u can have higher monthly payout.
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Goldmine - 09-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:44 PM)uncle168 Wrote: u can withdraw everything?
are u sure?
the cpf website even gave an example cannot leh
keekeekee
Bluff you for what. When u reach 55 u will know. Look forward to reaching 55 fast. How many more years to go?
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
but it only works if u intend to hit frs.
beyond that its stuck inside until u up lorry.
a lot of people happily thinks they can cash out the excess at 55.
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
it only works in monthly payout for those pioneer generation like my father.
after that is cpf life cannot take out in lump sum.
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Goldmine - 09-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:53 PM)uncle168 Wrote: it only works in monthly payout for those pioneer generation like my father.
after that is cpf life cannot take out in lump sum.
keekeekee
CPF Life is paid out monthly from age 65 from the FRS set aside.
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - [[ForeverAlone]] - 09-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:19 PM)uncle168 Wrote: that why i didn't transfer my oa to sa.
if u transfer $100k and earn $10k interest.
even if u have reach frs at 55 yrs old and left $120k in sa.
u can only withdraw $10k.
the only way u can withdraw the remaining $110k is when u die, your children can take.
keekeekee
This is why I keep telling others, Come on THINK SIMPLE. EVERYONE MAX THEIR SA , AND EVERYONE IS SO CALL " MILLIONAIRE " GOT ONE MILLION IN THEIR SA account.and " everyone withdraw " Govt can close shop and SG economics actually be in a HUGE mess.
imaging those batch everyone withdraw so call " million in their SA ".
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 09-07-2023
that's why cpf put under footnote.
sa is not a fd account ok.
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - winbig - 10-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:53 PM)uncle168 Wrote: it only works in monthly payout for those pioneer generation like my father.
after that is cpf life cannot take out in lump sum.
keekeekee
Whatever is in excess of FRS, u can take out in lump-sum if not wrong.
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - sgbuffett - 10-07-2023
The CPF is just a saving scheme.
When you reach 65 you start get monthly payout from your RA until death.
You can make use of the scheme but cannot depend on it for retirement as it is not inflation adjusted.
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Alice Alicia - 10-07-2023
Just a legalized ponzi scheme.
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - lylcnn - 10-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 11:33 PM)uncle168 Wrote: that's why cpf put under footnote.
sa is not a fd account ok.
keekeekee
Which example showed you that withdrawal not allowed? All us understand is can
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - RiseofAsia - 10-07-2023
(10-07-2023, 08:02 AM)sgbuffett Wrote: The CPF is just a saving scheme.
When you reach 65 you start get monthly payout from your RA until death.
You can make use of the scheme but cannot depend on it for retirement as it is not inflation adjusted.
You change their objective?
CPF is a life annuity with lousy return and full of restrictions lah.
See US Bond, much higher yield the CPF yield.
![[Image: IMG-8619.png]](https://i.ibb.co/FXHY33b/IMG-8619.png)
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Wy:Nox - 10-07-2023
(10-07-2023, 09:46 AM)Alice Alicia Wrote: Just a legalized ponzi scheme.
Another CPF Scam. Wonder how many of us were cheated 20 years ago. It is frustrating that my own money yet I cannot transfer between two accounts! This is worst than Daylight Robbery. The only choice is to vote them out.
T3T - T3T - 10-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:22 PM)uncle168 Wrote: https://www.cpf.gov.sg/member/faq/retirement-income/retirement-withdrawals/how-is-the-withdrawable-amount-computedYour link never said say cannot withdraw excess of frs from sa, can you provide example or screenshot of your claim?
* Excluding interest earned, any government grants received and top-ups made under the Retirement Sum Topping-up Scheme.
Keekeekee, or do you want to change your name to uncle162horland 😄
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - p1acebo - 10-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:38 PM)Goldmine Wrote: When you reached 55, u can withdraw all balances in yr O/A and S/A provided your FRS is met.
This is correct. Scary sial this TS post a lot of misinformation
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 10-07-2023
its quite vague leh.
i don't dare to transfer wait kenna stuck.
keekeekee
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - Wy:Nox - 10-07-2023
(09-07-2023, 10:38 PM)Goldmine Wrote: When you reached 55, u can withdraw all balances in yr O/A and S/A provided your FRS is met.
How many of us can reach $198,800 FRS at 55 years old?
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - lylcnn - 10-07-2023
Please call or email CPF, get their answer, then report back here
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - T3T - 10-07-2023
(10-07-2023, 01:22 PM)uncle168 Wrote: its quite vague leh.
i don't dare to transfer wait kenna stuck.
keekeekee
But your title not vague, assert that cannot withdraw.. why? Should not you change the title?
RE: if u transfer cpf oa to sa, the amount+interest cannot be withdrawn - uncle168 - 10-07-2023
but you also don't have any links from cpf to show can withdraw all if hit frs.
keekeekee