Manipur violence fuels calls for separate state in India
#1

Amrit Dhillon in New Delhi
Tue 16 May 2023 03.23 BST


......

an eruption of ethnic violence in which more than 70 were murdered and 30,000 forced to flee.

The bloodshed which began on 3 May has mostly abated, but there is little hope of a swift return to normality.

Food is scarce; a curfew is still enforced by the army and paramilitary troops; the internet remains suspended; shops, schools and offices are closed; thousands of people remain stranded in crowded and unsanitary refugee camps. And reports of fresh violence over the weekend prompted fresh displacements.

“This is a civil war situation,” said John Mamang, a lawyer and relief volunteer in the town of Churachandpur.

A villager inspects the debris of a ransacked church that was set alight during ethnic violence in Heirokland.

Shortages of food and medicine are becoming acute, said Mamang, who on Monday was unable to even find rice to donate to a nearby camp.

“People are beginning to starve. Some haven’t eaten for two to three days. When I reached the camp, a woman had just delivered a baby, with no medicines or medical help and in the clothes she’d been wearing for five days,” he said.

Most of the victims were from the mainly Christian hill tribes such as the Kukis, but members of the mostly Hindu Meitei people were also targeted.

......

Moses Varte, a Kuki in Churachandpur, said “separation is the only answer”, adding “This was ethnic cleansing of the hill people. Now we can only feel safe as a minority if we have our own state.”

......

The fact that Kukis were targeted in the city – despite the presence of security forces – has for many hill tribe members underlined a sense that they cannot be safe anywhere in the state.

......

The spark for the latest outbreak of violence in Manipur was a plan to grant the majority Meitei the status of a “scheduled tribe” which would give them access to quotas in government jobs and colleges under India’s affirmative action policy.

Tribal leaders say the Meiteis are already better off and dominate the government, police, and civil service. Granting them more privileges would be unfair, the Kukis argue, and would allow the Meiteis access to the forest lands which have been occupied by the tribes for centuries.

......

Police have been accused of favouring the majority Meitei community. The Kukis evacuated to the safety of army-run camps claimed police did not defend them, or even joined the mobs.

......

“The physical separation that’s already there will now become complete segregation. That, I think, will form the basis for a separate hill state,” said Fimsangpui. “We can no longer trust the Manipur government. It does not want to protect us. And we do not want to forget the cries of those who died. We have to keep the memory of them alive.”


https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/m...e-in-india
[+] 4 users Like Levin's post
Reply
#2

Taiwan also many different hill tribe ppl how come they can settle peacefully whereas for India it is not the same? Lousy govt?
[+] 2 users Like sgh's post
Reply
#3

North-East Indian States should join China and huat big big!
[+] 1 user Likes cityhantam's post
Reply
#4

This is WHY LKY already mention before India is unsettle can't be fix itself is hard whereas his son go pro india zzzz
[+] 2 users Like [[ForeverAlone]]'s post
Reply
#5

Such hatred probably accumulated over decades then erupt imto violence.

Usually the reason is economic jealousy. You have a small minority doing much better than majority who are poor. This minority stays separate and distant becomes target. Like indonesian Chinese ...LA riots Koreans were targeted.

I, being poor, have only my dreams; I have spread my dreams under your feet; Tread softly because you tread on my dreams.
Reply
#6

(16-05-2023, 07:18 PM)sgbuffett Wrote:  Such hatred probably accumulated over decades then erupt imto violence.

Violence is common in many parts of India, especially Kashmir and North-Eastern States.
Reply
#7

(16-05-2023, 07:18 PM)sgbuffett Wrote:  Such hatred probably accumulated over decades then erupt imto violence.

Usually the reason is economic jealousy. You have a small minority doing much better than majority who are poor. This minority stays separate and distant becomes target. Like indonesian Chinese ...LA riots Koreans were targeted.

It's the other way round here. In this case, the majority is doing better than the minority that is poorer. Then the state come up with a policy where this richer majority is to be the designated tribe making them to be even richer in the future. The minority objected and thus the majority took revenge on them for objecting.
Reply
#8

(16-05-2023, 07:27 PM)Levin Wrote:  It's the other way round here. In this case, the majority is doing better than the minority that is poorer. Then the state come up with a policy where this richer majority is to be the designated tribe making them to be even richer in the future. The minority objected and thus the majority took revenge on them for objecting.
One problem with democracy is the tyranny of the majority. Basically if a majority can vote a govt to bully a minority. Here is where special rights come in like what they did in Malaysia and taiwan where there are also many small native groups.


I, being poor, have only my dreams; I have spread my dreams under your feet; Tread softly because you tread on my dreams.
Reply
#9

(16-05-2023, 04:36 PM)sgh Wrote:  Taiwan also many different hill tribe ppl how come they can settle peacefully whereas for India it is not the same? Lousy govt?

They speak common langauge?.
Reply
#10

(16-05-2023, 04:40 PM)cityhantam Wrote:  North-East Indian States should join China and huat big big!

There a few ethnic races there, some of them are also living in Myanmar. 
So many times India and Myanmar govt are working together to suppress
the separatist movement. 
China govt very unlikely to land into such trouble.
Reply
#11

(16-05-2023, 09:03 PM)Blin Wrote:  They speak common langauge?.

Their languages are different, but all able to speak Mandrain these days.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)