S'porean monk explains why paper offering are made..and why it is not needed...
#1

I hope I do not hurt anybody religious feelings. But to think that burning something made of paper will appear in the here after as the real thing is not very scientific. I tried to explain to my mom many times it is not necessary. Her reply is if not necessary why people do it for last 1000yrs.

https://mothership.sg/2021/08/hungry-gho...r-burning/

I, being poor, have only my dreams; I have spread my dreams under your feet; Tread softly because you tread on my dreams.
Reply
#2

That's what Buddha found out after visiting all realms of existence and told his elder disciple, Ananda........... Rolleyes

 Thinking is difficult, that's why most people judge
                    Carl Jung
Reply
#3

Depending on taoist monk or buddhist monk.
[+] 1 user Likes A2Z's post
Reply
#4

I remembered i help to fold those old fashion paper gold ingots back then. Should just burn some paper bitcoin since it is 2021
[+] 1 user Likes pinkpanther's post
Reply
#5

I burnt clothes, gold, money.
Reply
#6

[Image: 20160502003375.jpg]Use this app and this hologram device betterer......

Confused
Reply
#7

People already burnt paper masks and vaccines mostly Pfizer and Sinovac for their passed away love ones as they afraid they.might not be allowed into restaurants on the other side...... Rolleyes

 Thinking is difficult, that's why most people judge
                    Carl Jung
Reply
#8

that's a good topic!
I suppose many believers are just following their ancestor footstep without even understanding the origin. Hokkien always like to say 'wu bai wu bo bi'.
So everything also 'bi lor'. From offering to commercializing.
Reply
#9

There r MNCs still practising the traditional offerings

There is no right or wrong decisions. 
One only has to bear the consequences that one makes  Big Grin
Reply
#10

The shops that sell these paper offerings need to make a living. If you ask them, they will say that the paper offerings will appear as real in the underworld. So have to burn, if not the ghost will suffer in hell.

Real or not? Have they gone to the underworld and experience it and came back to tell????
Reply
#11

Retold many time by my relatives- cousin who died of liver cancer came out in the middle of the night, gave a tap on brother's shoulder (he woke up in the middle of the night to pee).Next morning told mother who consulted a taoist medium who explained that dead son could not received all those paper gold, food, etc. Of course aunt quickly prayed and burned in a separate urn. At one time Hbd gave a very big drum urn for everyone to share in burning the paper gold, etc
Reply
#12

seriously think this practice need more control. during cheng meng at guangmingshan, u see mountains of boxes/clothes/aeroplane/houses waiting to burn.. pple shd adopt other more environmental friendly means to pray. at least if u pray with food, u still get to eat it.
Reply
#13

(19-08-2021, 10:33 AM)OLT Wrote:  seriously think this practice need more control.  during cheng meng at guangmingshan, u see mountains of boxes/clothes/aeroplane/houses waiting to burn.. pple shd adopt other more environmental friendly means to pray.  at least if u pray with food, u still get to eat it.

Food after praying.are tasteless. ....... Rolleyes

 Thinking is difficult, that's why most people judge
                    Carl Jung
Reply
#14

(19-08-2021, 10:37 AM)Huliwang Wrote:  Good after praying.are tasteless. ....... Rolleyes

lol where got such thing... i only know food after praying is cold, and sometime got abit of ashes on top.

Laughing
Reply
#15

(19-08-2021, 10:39 AM)OLT Wrote:  lol where got such thing... i only know food after praying is cold, and sometime got abit of ashes on top.

Laughing

Everyone say wan. That's why nowadays you see plenty food on roadside after seven and half month praying........ Rolleyes

 Thinking is difficult, that's why most people judge
                    Carl Jung
Reply
#16

religion believe and practice cannot be explained scientifically.

it is whether you believe it or not.
Reply
#17

(19-08-2021, 09:18 AM)pinkpanther Wrote:  I remembered i help to fold those old fashion paper gold ingots back then. Should just burn some paper bitcoin since it is 2021

Only gold and silver paper accepted in Hell.
Not paper bitcoin or paper currency.
This is why they are folded into 元宝。
The rest of the $$$, are not legal tendered in Hell.
You will waste your money buying all these stuffs.

Their rules and human rules are different, cannot anyhow change as they like like us to suit our own agenda. 会犯天规。

“Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind"
Reply
#18

(19-08-2021, 08:43 AM)sgbuffett Wrote:  I hope I do not hurt anybody religious feelings. But to think that burning something made of paper will appear in the here after as the real thing is not very scientific. I tried to explain to my mom many times it is not necessary. Her reply is if not necessary why people do it for last 1000yrs.

https://mothership.sg/2021/08/hungry-gho...r-burning/

It is a custom or tradition.
You can dont believe, but you cant force ppl to follow your way.
Do you know many scientists and professors have become monks?

One very good teaching about buddhism is that human beings are actually God but they are blinded by cravings and desires. Once all these cravings and desires eradicate, they will attain Nirvana in Buddhist concept. Meaning become God in layman term.

They are total 10 superpowers you may attain during your enlightenment cycle if I did not remember wrongly.
Have you heard of 天眼通, this is only basic level?

“Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind"
Reply
#19

Ask those with 3rd eye to report what they see during 7th month joss burnings and road side offerings
Reply
#20

If hell is all about sufferings, why do you need these hell notes for?
Reply
#21

(19-08-2021, 01:52 PM)pinkpanther Wrote:  If hell is all about sufferings, why do you need these hell notes for?
Buddhist got 6 realms of existences and Hindu got 31 planes of existences.

The six realms of Buddhist existences are..
God
Demi God
Human
Animal
Ghost
Hell

Those notes the Chinese burnt are for the ghost realm but for communication purposes, hell note is used for convenience. 

The hell realm is just a torture pit with 18 chambers of different torture.methods.
Rolleyes

 Thinking is difficult, that's why most people judge
                    Carl Jung
Reply
#22

those electronic gadgets and cars cannot be used without power, so no point lah
Reply
#23

I think these burning of money and other offerings to the dead are for relieving the conscience and guilts of those livings doing the offerings. They feel more at peace and have better dreams instead of nightmares. 
For example my grandma wud dreamt often of my grandpa appearing in her dreams without shirt and living in a tent. After deciphering her dreams she would burn some paper shirts, shoes, hats and a bungalow for my grandpa. After that she feel peaceful and had good dreams. This is just one example of how burning offerings help the livings........ Rolleyes

 Thinking is difficult, that's why most people judge
                    Carl Jung
[+] 1 user Likes Huliwang's post
Reply
#24

(19-08-2021, 01:52 PM)pinkpanther Wrote:  If hell is all about sufferings, why do you need these hell notes for?

to bribe the cow head horse face to give chance, adjust temperature of oil to 30degree, change steel sabre to plastic one, buy some pig tongue to replace human.. or ghost tongue..  etc.
[+] 1 user Likes OLT's post
Reply
#25

(19-08-2021, 03:10 PM)OLT Wrote:  to bribe the cow head horse face to give chance, adjust temperature of oil to 30degree, change steel sabre to plastic one, buy some pig tongue to replace human.. or ghost tongue..  etc.

This is becos both of them dont have God appts.
Some Supertitious ppl think they are only Ghost constables.
This is why they believe that both of them can be bribed.

“Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind"
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)