[Bigiron]

Tan See Leng’s job growth claim questioned: 1 in 3 "new" PMETs were just reclassified - The Online Citizen
https://www.theonlinecitizen.com/2025/03...lassified/

https://youtu.be/kOX17X1sMbQ?si=DAfbhtWGKCyD2-oi

[Wy:Nox]

If every year an average of 20,000 foreigners are issued Citizenship, past 12 years would have accumulated 240k with at least half are working adults. So, it does not make a logic to MP TSL’s claim which is likely inaccurate or deliberate attempt to confuse us.

https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/t...p-ceremony

[Ola]

If every year an average of 200,000 foreigners are issued Citizenship, past 12 years would have accumulated 2.4 Million with at least half are working adults. So, it does not make a logic to MP TSL’s claim which is likely inaccurate or deliberate attempt to confuse us.

https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/t...p-ceremony

Now GE coming, all their BS appearing

More Ang Bao to bribe us

they spending more time to Fix Opposition

and re-drawing boundaries again to win votes 




Anything new??

[KILLjoy]

he can say whatever he wants to

and what can you do about it?

nothing.... nothing.... nothing.... nothing....

LLST....

this is little red menses dot

[Gemstar]

knnbccbai, stop spreading lies!

AI Overview


In 2023, Singapore granted citizenship to 23,472 people. This is a slight increase from the previous five years. 
Details

• About 5.7% of the new citizens were children born overseas to Singaporean parents 
  
• The average number of new citizenships granted per year over the last five years is slightly higher than the previous five years 
  
• The pace of immigration is considered measured and stable 
  
• The government's commitment is to foster a dynamic, diverse population 
  

Eligibility

To apply for citizenship, applicants must be at least 21 years old and have been a permanent resident of Singapore for at least two years. 
Previous years 

• In 2022, 23,082 people were granted citizenship
  
• In 2021, the application approval rate for citizenship was 18%
  
• In 2018, 22,550 people were granted citizenship
  

They are clear facts and not lies. And you believed and trust those datas so much? Also, I never count those datas personally to prove it.

[Bigiron]

Tan See Leng’s Job Growth Claim Questioned: 1 in 3 "New" PMETs Were Just Reclassified - The Online Citizen
 
Source: The Online Citizen
Published: 2025-03-07
 
Author: Not specified
 
Article Summary:
 
Theme: This news article critically examines Minister Tan See Leng's claims of robust PMET job growth in Singapore, arguing that a significant portion of this growth might be due to job reclassification rather than genuine job creation.
 
Core Points:
 
- PMET Job Growth Questioned: The article challenges the government's assertion that 63% of PMET job growth benefited local-born Singaporeans. It argues that a substantial proportion of these jobs resulted from the reclassification of existing roles rather than new job creation.
 
- Reclassification Issue: The article highlights that while the government claims a significant increase in PMET jobs, the overall resident workforce growth does not match the number of new PMET positions. This suggests that many workers may have been reclassified from non-PMET roles to PMET roles without a substantial change in their job scope, salary, or career prospects.
 
- Underemployment Concerns: The article raises concerns about underemployment, arguing that many Singaporeans may be counted as "employed" but are working fewer hours, earning lower wages, or holding unstable, temporary positions.
 
- Data Transparency: The article emphasizes the need for greater transparency in the government's data on employment figures, including a clear distinction between reclassified jobs and genuinely new employment opportunities.
 
- Lack of Fairness in Debate: The article criticizes Minister Tan's response to MP Leong Mun Wai's concerns, suggesting that his remarks were dismissive and did not address the legitimate concerns raised.
 
Phenomenon:
 
- Job Reclassification: The article examines the phenomenon of job reclassification, where existing roles are recategorized as PMET roles, potentially masking actual job creation and underemployment issues.
 
- Underemployment: The article explores the phenomenon of underemployment, where workers are technically considered employed but hold positions that are not fulfilling their needs, offering limited job security, or providing lower wages.
 
Additional Points:
 
- The article cites various statistics and data points to support its claims, including:
 
- The decline in clerical support workers and other roles that are traditionally associated with non-PMET positions.
 
- The rise in "Associate Professionals & Technicians," which overlaps with the reclassification of administrative roles.
 
- The fact that the growth in resident employment does not align with the reported increase in PMET jobs.
 
- The article raises several crucial questions about the government's job growth narrative:
 
- How many of the new PMET jobs were actually new jobs, and how many were reclassified roles?
 
- What proportion of these PMET jobs went to local-born citizens, rather than PRs or new citizens?
 
- How many Singaporeans are actually underemployed?
 
- The article calls for greater transparency in the government's data and a more substantive debate on labor issues, arguing that the government needs to provide a clearer picture of the employment landscape and address the concerns about underemployment and job reclassification.

[Bigiron]

Watch Is the Job Market Really Growing
https://vimeo.com/1063780849

Watch Endless Work, Broken Dreams_ The Reality
https://vimeo.com/1063780919

[Gemstar]

he can say whatever he wants to

and what can you do about it?

nothing.... nothing.... nothing.... nothing....

LLST....

this is little red menses dot

They are clear facts and not lies. And you believed and trust those datas so much? Also, I never count those datas personally to prove it.

Maybe, those datas needs to be independently audited to prove its worth. Of course, cannot punish those whistleblowers whose datas turned out to be otherwise.

[Wy:Nox]

My typo error with additional 0. Corrected my comments. Fortunately, there is a link I provided. However, if we add the huge PRs and Foreigners, his numbers still do not make sense.

[Ernesto]

When one dun speak the truth yet the whole crony still feel arrogant, that's dangerous being on Earth.

[Symmetry]

Seems that some accounting games were played and people do not believe what was presented by MP TSL. I would not believe either as this same question was raised a few times but took them many years to finally come up with this. So where is the catch?

[Tee tiong huat]

Watch the Job Market Really Growing
https://vimeo.com/1063780849

Watch Endless Work, Broken Dreams_ The Reality
https://vimeo.com/1063780919

What I like best his or about him, is his Cantonese word  speaking. Best in S'pore parliament. Rotfl