Tan see leng didn't answer the question from Gerald giam
#1

https://youtu.be/iRUxHFDxcJ8?si=5AkEcZ4wM6B7Besh

Here are the micro-expressions, body language, hedging statements, and roundabout answers from Tan See Leng as well as quotes from him with timestamps:

[00:00:32]

“We work collectively as an ecosystem.”

Begins to fidget with the lapel.

“So, MOM, MTI, and other economic agencies.”

A slight blink of the eye.

“Monitoring how Singapore performs at a macro level, and of course this include includes the competitiveness of uh Singapore economy as well as how it translates into good employment outcomes for our locals. At the upcoming COS when MOM has the opportunity we will give a sort of balanced scorecard update as to how the performance have been.”

[00:01:01]

More pronounced fiddling.

“I think the one point that um I would like uh to also uh perhaps alert the member too is that when it comes to top global talent, the proverbial rainmakers, the ones that can bring deals, that can crowd in, they can attract they’re super magnet for talent. You know, enhancing reinforcing our competitiveness as a hub for global talent, we can never have enough.”

[00:01:32]

More comfortable and confident.

“So, in terms of a specific target, you know, for KPI you’re not like running a business uh where you can set the return on on on on equity, return on investment. I think we should be thinking in terms of a measure of what kind of return of social equity that we would need to to think about in terms of imputing this type of balance scorecard measure. And in a sense itself we will work across our entire ecosystem with all the different government ministry.”

[00:02:02]

“Now, what we have done for MOM, because this program only started barely two years ago, we have already started an annual notification for the existing one-pass holders in September last year, so about three three and a half four months back. We will be reviewing the data that we collect uh we will also be evaluating their contributions to Singapore.”

Slight forward leaning, more enthusiastic

[00:02:27]

Continues enthusiastic delivery.

“I want to once again reinforce, the impact of one pass holders goes beyond the individual contributions and also the immediate tangible output that can be measured, because for the longer term sustainable ecosystem that we endeavor, we aspire to build and to succeed, we need to continue to ensure that our only resource and that of the highest form of human resource, our talent continues to be here to be well anchored here, and then I think we will continue to succeed in making Singapore attractive to leading firms and also investors. I hope that addresses the member’s point, thank you.”

[00:03:39]

Slight lip purse.

“I have also shared in my SQ that we will be sending up notification letters, and in terms of understanding the different segments of the one-pass holders today that resides in Singapore it would then allow us to be a lot more targeted in leveraging on their expertise in leveraging on their networks and also leveraging on their skill sets to be able to to work closely and to transfer those skill sets, to mentor our locals and given the fact that today it's really maybe perhaps one and a half two years into the program itself um the data that we have fundamentally uh as I said, the biggest group are in financial services in uh infocomms and in professional services, some of the programs we've curated in those kind of areas for them to be able to to to produce I mean to come up with uh capability transfer programs. Rather than for us to mandate that they have to do that, we would prefer to work with a more encouraging tone, working with them, getting them to inspire our successive successive generations of Singaporeans to to think outside of the box. I hope that gives you that that context. Thank you.”

Tan See Leng's responses seem to address the questions in a roundabout way without providing specific numbers or direct answers.
Reply
#2

In a parliamentary session, Workers' Party MP Gerald Giam inquired about specific key performance indicators (KPIs) for evaluating the effectiveness of the Overseas Networks & Expertise Pass (ONE Pass) in attracting top global talent to Singapore. Manpower Minister Tan See Leng responded by emphasizing a holistic approach, highlighting collaboration among various ministries and agencies to monitor Singapore's macroeconomic performance and employment outcomes. He noted the challenges in setting precise KPIs for attracting high-caliber talent, referring to them as "rainmakers" who enhance the nation's competitiveness. Tan suggested that the impact of such talent extends beyond immediate measurable outputs, contributing to long-term ecosystem development. He mentioned ongoing evaluations of ONE Pass holders but did not provide specific metrics or targets in his response.
Reply
#3

Tan See Leng's Response to Gerald Giam's Question
 
Title: Tan see leng didn't answer the question from Gerald giam
 
Source: sgtalk.net
 
Publication Date: 2025-02-07
 
Author: Not provided
 
Theme: This article analyzes Tan See Leng's response to a question posed by Gerald Giam regarding the effectiveness of the "One Pass" program for attracting top global talent.
 
Core Points:
 
- Tan See Leng avoids giving specific numbers or direct answers.
 
- He emphasizes the importance of a "balanced scorecard" approach to assess the program's success.
 
- He highlights the program's impact on attracting talent and fostering a "sustainable ecosystem."
 
- Tan See Leng stresses the need for a "more encouraging tone" and working with "one-pass" holders to inspire future generations of Singaporeans.
 
Conclusion:
 
Tan See Leng's response is characterized by roundabout answers and a focus on the broader context of the "One Pass" program. While acknowledging the program's importance, he fails to provide concrete data or clear metrics for its effectiveness. This approach leaves the question of the program's success unanswered and raises concerns about transparency and accountability.
[+] 1 user Likes Bigiron's post
Reply
#4

SM LJ ONE Pass?

Why do we need 5 Mayors and 80 PAP Ministers? 
[+] 1 user Likes Ola's post
Reply
#5

All those who try to evade questions or failed to give relevant answers are mere losers.
[+] 2 users Like Gemstar's post
Reply
#6

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapor...ng-4888481

Even this portion of the clarifies still left doubts and ambiguity to his own reply.

[Image: IMG-2695.jpg]
[+] 2 users Like Wy:Nox's post
Reply
#7

meanwhile, locals get the short end of the stick, like this gal

https://tinyurl.com/mwnz5mtt
[+] 1 user Likes pinkypanther's post
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)