SG Talk

Full Version: What does meritocracy mean in S'pore?
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Our Govt talks a lot about meritocracy  A meritocracy is a social system where people receive status or rewards based on what they achieve, and not because of their wealth or social status. So is meritocracy practiced when all 3 children of Lee Kuan Yew become President’s Scholars, and the 2 sons obtain SAF scholarships with 1 becoming Prime Minister?  Is it meritocracy when S'pore’s PM is married to the most powerful woman – Ho Ching when she was the former CEO of Temasek? Is meritocracy at play when former President Tony Tan’s son Patrick and daughter Patricia became President’s Scholars? Patrick was granted an unheard-of 12 years’ disruption from NS to complete further studies, and eventually served in the specially created post of medical researcher.
Is meritocracy practiced when SAF Generals with zero private sector experience and zero industry experience are appointed CEOs of SMRT? Is meritocracy at play when Generals and SAF Scholars are systematically inducted into the top echelons of the govt and govt-linked corporations? Lee Hsien Loong, Teo Chee Hean, Chan Chun Sing, Tan Chuan-Jin, Ng Chee Meng, Ng Chee Kern, Ng Chee Peng, Neo Kian Hong and Ng Yat Chung are included in that list.
Meritocracy may even be reinterpreted – the Elected Presidency becomes reserved for Malay candidates only; and only 1 candidate (based on merit) qualifies and automatically becomes President. The selected President may even be an Indian woman who is miraculously transformed into a Malay! 
(11-03-2024, 02:01 PM)EvertonDiehard Wrote: [ -> ]Our Govt talks a lot about meritocracy  A meritocracy is a social system where people receive status or rewards based on what they achieve, and not because of their wealth or social status. So is meritocracy practiced when all 3 children of Lee Kuan Yew become President’s Scholars, and the 2 sons obtain SAF scholarships with 1 becoming Prime Minister?  Is it meritocracy when S'pore’s PM is married to the most powerful woman – Ho Ching when she was the former CEO of Temasek? Is meritocracy at play when former President Tony Tan’s son Patrick and daughter Patricia became President’s Scholars? Patrick was granted an unheard-of 12 years’ disruption from NS to complete further studies, and eventually served in the specially created post of medical researcher.

(11-03-2024, 02:05 PM)EvertonDiehard Wrote: [ -> ]Is meritocracy practiced when SAF Generals with zero private sector experience and zero industry experience are appointed CEOs of SMRT? Is meritocracy at play when Generals and SAF Scholars are systematically inducted into the top echelons of the govt and govt-linked corporations? Lee Hsien Loong, Teo Chee Hean, Chan Chun Sing, Tan Chuan-Jin, Ng Chee Meng, Ng Chee Kern, Ng Chee Peng, Neo Kian Hong and Ng Yat Chung are included in that list.

(11-03-2024, 02:08 PM)EvertonDiehard Wrote: [ -> ]Meritocracy may even be reinterpreted – the Elected Presidency becomes reserved for Malay candidates only; and only 1 candidate (based on merit) qualifies and automatically becomes President. The selected President may even be an Indian woman who is miraculously transformed into a Malay! 



bro...............i intend to quote your 3 messages into my battle-cry slogan for GE2024.................at Reddit...........
Sg is Elitism not meritocracy lah
Dont be misled by current team.

If Sg is a meritocracy society, the best ppl will now be serving the nation irregardless whether he/she from which place he/she comes from or party.
If cannot eat the grape ; want to say it is sweet ?
(11-03-2024, 08:09 PM)Napoleon Porlumpar Wrote: [ -> ]bro...............i intend to quote your 3 messages into my battle-cry slogan for GE2024.................at Reddit...........

Hiring close allies may give the impression that the PM/ruling party is weak and requires a network of supporters to strengthen their position. Cronyism casts aspersions on a leader’s judgment and ethics when Ministers/MPs lack the requisite skills, knowledge and experience, which will become apparent over time.
[Image: 20230506_IRC015.png]
dont read too much n take meritocracy seriously in spore n anywhere

relationship comes b4 this selectionfor the best person for the job
What was this Ingkiriwang Huang's achievement in Temasek?


[Image: Shawn-Huang-Ikirawng.png]
(11-03-2024, 08:12 PM)RiseofAsia Wrote: [ -> ]Sg is Elitism not meritocracy lah
Dont be misled by current team.
If Sg is a meritocracy society, the best ppl will now be serving the nation irregardless whether he/she from which place he/she comes from or party.

meritocracy is nowadays frequently associate with 举贤不避亲 choose capable over fear of conflict of interest
right or wrong society have to decide.
(12-03-2024, 07:30 PM)talky Wrote: [ -> ]dont read too much n take meritocracy seriously in spore n anywhere relationship comes b4 this selection for the best person for the job

Instead of the best man (or woman) for the job, it is always the best friend.
Pap is running a mediocracy, not meritocracy.


[Image: Screenshot-2024-03-12-23-30-51-48-40deb4...480b12.jpg]
(12-03-2024, 11:33 PM)Alice Alicia Wrote: [ -> ]Pap is running a mediocracy, not meritocracy.


[Image: Screenshot-2024-03-12-23-30-51-48-40deb4...480b12.jpg]

that sounds about right!
(11-03-2024, 02:05 PM)EvertonDiehard Wrote: [ -> ]Is meritocracy practiced when SAF Generals with zero private sector experience and zero industry experience are appointed CEOs of SMRT? Is meritocracy at play when Generals and SAF Scholars are systematically inducted into the top echelons of the govt and govt-linked corporations? Lee Hsien Loong, Teo Chee Hean, Chan Chun Sing, Tan Chuan-Jin, Ng Chee Meng, Ng Chee Kern, Ng Chee Peng, Neo Kian Hong and Ng Yat Chung are included in that list.
Lui T Y?