Posts: 16,655
   
Threads: 0
    
Likes Received: 4,236 in 3,862 posts
Likes Given: 3,504
(10 hours ago)Ali Imran Wrote: But eating the flesh of a man and drinking his blood. Is that weird? Yes, many will find it weird.
Go bite your father’s pee is not weird ?
As a dog returns to its vomit, so fools repeat their folly
>
Posts: 8,681
   
Threads: 0
    
Likes Received: 253 in 243 posts
Likes Given: 78
(8 hours ago)Lukongsimi Wrote: Go bite your father’s pee is not weird ?
Do we do that? The answer is no.
Do Christians perform the Eucharist? The answer is yes.
Posts: 16,655
   
Threads: 0
    
Likes Received: 4,236 in 3,862 posts
Likes Given: 3,504
(8 hours ago)Ali Imran Wrote: Do we do that? The answer is no.
Do Christians perform the Eucharist? The answer is yes.
[color=oklch(0.2 0 0)]
Detailed discussion about the hadith “Tell him to bite his father’s male member” and refutation of those who say that this is gratuitously obscene speech[/color]
[color=oklch(0.2 0 0)]
Question: 121823
An atheist asked me: How could the Messenger (peace be upon him) speak obscene words, when he is a Prophet, such as “Tell him to bite his father’s male member”, and approve of Abu Bakr saying, “Suck the clitoris of al-Laat”, even though the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) forbade obscene speech? [/color]
As a dog returns to its vomit, so fools repeat their folly
>
Posts: 12,601
   
Threads: 201
    
Likes Received: 3,056 in 2,674 posts
Likes Given: 1,889
(8 hours ago)Ali Imran Wrote: It is known as Shahadahtain, meaning two Shahadahs. One is declaring that there is no god but Allah, and the other is declaring that Muhammad is a servant of Allah.
So, two sentences, if you want to be pedantic about it.
Is Muhammad Allah's creation? If Yes then why are you declaring to His works?
(This post was last modified:
8 hours ago by
pinkpanther.)
Posts: 16,655
   
Threads: 0
    
Likes Received: 4,236 in 3,862 posts
Likes Given: 3,504
(10 hours ago)Ali Imran Wrote: We have manuscripts to prove that the Quran is preserved, well-preserved.
![[Image: Fm8cRykX0BAUZb-.jpg]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Fm8cRykX0BAUZb-.jpg)
The Quran is not preserved and is corrupted
The famous statement and belief is that “Allah” wrote the Quran. But did Allah truly write the Quran or was it revealed to Muhammad who was incapable of writing the Quran. It was actually revealed in 7 dialects from Allah because certain tribes or groups didn’t know how to speak the other dialects. Therefore, the different lands had different preservations and memorizations of the Quran which is why after Muhammad died (which is when Qurans started being written), muslims were at disagreement and war with each other. Muslims we’re calling other muslims disbelievers because they believed in a different Quran.
If the different Qurans say the same, why would they feel the need to call other ones disbelievers.. the differences had to be great, which I have examples. But back to the history, Caliph Uthman decided out of his own will (not Allah’s or Muhammad’s order) to destroy the other Allah Given Qurans by burning them (sin) and he chose a council of muslims (some were companions of Muhammad) and re created a standardized Quran. Not the original, but his version. Remember, Muhammad told these companions different versions of the Quran so many did disagree yet we are still here to believe that there is only one Quran, when actuality, there is more than 26 Qurans in Arabic where the words are changed, which changes the meaning.
So I ask again, is the Quran today actually Allah’s word, or is it corrupted like every religion is supposedly. Let’s not forget sheep ate pages. Others were lost.
And to debunk this theory, if they memorized it perfectly, which lets say they did.. Allah sent 7 dialects. Muhammad taught different versions. If they were the same, why would one muslim feel to call others disbelievers ? Why would Uthman feel the need to make HIS OWN PERSONAL QURAN WITHOUT DIVINE REVELATION or COMMAND ?
As a dog returns to its vomit, so fools repeat their folly
>
Posts: 8,681
   
Threads: 0
    
Likes Received: 253 in 243 posts
Likes Given: 78
(8 hours ago)Lukongsimi Wrote: The Quran is not preserved and is corrupted
The famous statement and belief is that “Allah” wrote the Quran. But did Allah truly write the Quran or was it revealed to Muhammad who was incapable of writing the Quran. It was actually revealed in 7 dialects from Allah because certain tribes or groups didn’t know how to speak the other dialects. Therefore, the different lands had different preservations and memorizations of the Quran which is why after Muhammad died (which is when Qurans started being written), muslims were at disagreement and war with each other. Muslims we’re calling other muslims disbelievers because they believed in a different Quran.
If the different Qurans say the same, why would they feel the need to call other ones disbelievers.. the differences had to be great, which I have examples. But back to the history, Caliph Uthman decided out of his own will (not Allah’s or Muhammad’s order) to destroy the other Allah Given Qurans by burning them (sin) and he chose a council of muslims (some were companions of Muhammad) and re created a standardized Quran. Not the original, but his version. Remember, Muhammad told these companions different versions of the Quran so many did disagree yet we are still here to believe that there is only one Quran, when actuality, there is more than 26 Qurans in Arabic where the words are changed, which changes the meaning.
So I ask again, is the Quran today actually Allah’s word, or is it corrupted like every religion is supposedly. Let’s not forget sheep ate pages. Others were lost.
And to debunk this theory, if they memorized it perfectly, which lets say they did.. Allah sent 7 dialects. Muhammad taught different versions. If they were the same, why would one muslim feel to call others disbelievers ? Why would Uthman feel the need to make HIS OWN PERSONAL QURAN WITHOUT DIVINE REVELATION or COMMAND ?
You said the Quran is corrupted, but you have no proof.
I say the Quran is preserved, and I have proof.
Posts: 16,655
   
Threads: 0
    
Likes Received: 4,236 in 3,862 posts
Likes Given: 3,504
(9 hours ago)Ali Imran Wrote: Allah is one (Quran 112:1). Allah has no partners.
Any questions on that?
The true God has Son and Holy Spirit
As a dog returns to its vomit, so fools repeat their folly
>
Posts: 8,681
   
Threads: 0
    
Likes Received: 253 in 243 posts
Likes Given: 78
(8 hours ago)pinkpanther Wrote: Is Muhammad Allah's creation? If Yes then why are you declaring to His works?
Yes, we believe Muhammad صلي الله عليه وسلم is Allah's creation, a servant of Allah. We declare our faith.
Users browsing this thread: Lukongsimi*, 37 Guest(s)