[Bigiron]

Shanmugam, Leong Mun Wai exchange words over Singapore's race-based policies https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapor...ng-4918221

[Bigiron]

Shanmugam, Leong Mun Wai Exchange Words Over Singapore's Race-Based Policies
 
Source: Channel NewsAsia, February 5, 2025
 
Article Summary:
 
Theme: The article details a heated exchange between Minister K Shanmugam and Non-Constituency Member of Parliament (NCMP) Leong Mun Wai in Singapore's parliament, focusing on the government's race-based policies, particularly the CMIO framework and its implications.
 
Core Points:
 
- CMIO Framework: Minister Shanmugam defended the Chinese-Malay-Indian-Others (CMIO) model, claiming it has effectively promoted racial harmony and is crucial for administering race-based policies like the Ethnic Integration Policy (EIP).
 
- Leong's Critique: Mr. Leong questioned the CMIO framework, citing Minister Edwin Tong's suggestion for a review and arguing that the EIP carries economic disadvantages for minorities. He proposed compensation for these disadvantages.
 
- Shanmugam's Rebuttal: Minister Shanmugam accused Mr. Leong of having "very different perspectives" on race-based policies and highlighted past comments deemed racist. He cited Mr. Leong's statements regarding HDB living and his comments on the Singapore-India Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA).
 
- Defense of EIP: The Minister reiterated the EIP's significance for ensuring housing integration and good management of housing estates.
 
- Concerns Over Removing CMIO: The Minister argued that removing the CMIO framework could lead to worse outcomes based on evidence from other countries, such as France's experience with banning race-based data collection.
 
Exchange Highlights:
 
- Minister Shanmugam used Mr. Leong's past comments as evidence to discredit his arguments against the CMIO framework, emphasizing the importance of multiracial harmony in Singapore.
 
- Mr. Leong countered by stating that his party supports the EIP but advocates for economic compensation for minorities.
 
- The exchange highlighted contrasting views on the CMIO framework and the effectiveness of race-based policies.
 
Key Takeaways:
 
- The CMIO framework remains a contentious issue in Singapore, with differing opinions on its effectiveness and implications for racial harmony.
 
- The debate highlights the complexities of race-based policies and the delicate balance between promoting social cohesion and addressing potential economic disparities.
 
- The exchange underscores the importance of careful consideration and transparent discussion when addressing sensitive issues like race and social policy.

[[[ForeverAlone]]]

Sham only good to bully local aka opposition but come international timid like mouse

I still remember he talk negative on Trump and who knows trump come sg and he go MIA.

[grotesqueness]

nincompoop son PAP no more integrity
nincompoop son PAP no more trustworthy liao
nincompoop son PAP no more responsibility

[grotesqueness]

nincompoop son PAP is to buy your vote over

[Ola]

Sham is a childish brat who cannot discuss any topics

Talking about race and he accuses the other party of being racist

So talk about Transgender, he will call others Butch?

Or talk about road accidents, he will label others as murderers?

His legal profession is "Guility unless Proven Innocent"?

黑白双魔 ， he is the Male Character Assassinator in PAP

[moonrab]

So what is Leong view on CMIO?
Maintain or change the ratio?

[Migrant]

That fellow thunder very loud, but not a drop of rain.

[Wy:Nox]

PaP wanted Constructive Politics but how so without Constructive Parliament behaviour? MP Indranee should school Shanmugam which of course, is impossible because she herself has behaved badly.