[Ali Imran]

Now you want me to throw the scriptures away and argue on your terms...
If you judge solely on works...then those who committed crimes and evils have no chance to make it right....they will be condemned!

No, I didn't say throw away the scriptures. I just want to appeal to your thinking faculty, using logic.

I didn't say solely on works. If you don't want to believe, no amount of work is gonna save you in the hereafter. We all can agree on that. 

But we already know faith is a gift from God. That alone should be enough to reject your sola fide position. How can faith be the justification when it is a gift from God? It doesn't make sense.

And then there's that Tom example I gave you. How do you deal with that?