[S I M T A N]

Who has the truth? James or Paul? Only 1 of them can be right.

You're harping on Sola Fide again - this heresy exaggerates the truth concerning salvation by faith in Jesus Christ. And this is the umpteenth time you're trying to disprove and demolish the doctrine of justification by faith ALONE - one of the central tenets of the Christian faith - by pitting James against Paul.

Instead of simply stating "Paul said you don't need to follow the Law; James said you must follow the Law," have you considered the fact that terms like faith and works can have more than one meaning or application? Therefore, you should ask, "When Paul spoke of faith and works, what exactly did he mean?" and "When James used those terms, what did he mean?" When we explore these questions, we find that Paul and James did indeed use the terms faith and works in different ways and in different settings.

We can argue till kingdom comes and our disagreements will again lead us into a philosophical cul-de-sac. We can't argue with you for your mind is closed. But I think this issue is worth revisiting for the benefit of those who are curious to know more about it. Hopefully, the truth will lead some of them to place their faith in Christ.