[pinkpanther]

Pretend you're the companion and I'm the prophet.

You told me something I didn't know: that the universe is expanding and every living thing originates from water. And then I put it in a book and claim that I received that info from God. Would you know that I am lying about getting that info from God?

Now can you see how silly your claim is?

Your thinking is as backwards as Islam ..who says that Muhammad needs to be fed infomation from his companions  ...he was once a merchant and travelled on trading trips. He is bound to meet, listen and learn from people of all sorts from some market places..He remembered some stories and put it in the Quran..

AI Overview

Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was known for his wisdom and leadership, and his interactions with those around him played a crucial role in his personal and spiritual development. He learned from the people he encountered, including his family, companions, and even his opponents, by observing their actions, listening to their opinions, and engaging in discussions.