15-07-2025, 04:23 AM
(14-07-2025, 10:59 PM)Hope Wrote: Prophet Muhammad commentaries are in Arabic.
He didn’t speak English.Can you expect him to give commentary in English?He knew this problem. That is why he made us to recite Quran in Arabic only.
How are you sure that bible was interpreted correctly from Aramaic > Hebrew > Greek > English?
We have the original Quran in Arabic. Do you have the original bible in Aramaic?
Have you ever compared the bible verses in different languages ? Please forward few verses in these languages . Let’s check those interpretations.
Greek Vs English?
English Vs Chinese?
English Vs Malay?
English Vs Bahasa Indo?
You do not have Muhammad commentary or written Tafsir (exegesis of the Quran)...there may be some but not all the verses were explained by Muhammad
Scholars like Ibn Abbas, Ibn Jarir al-Tabari, al-Zamakhshari, Ibn Kathir, help Muhammad contribute to the tafsirs...
I'm telling you what matters is Muhammad's tafsir. Only he knows the real meanings behind his verses but unfortunately it was never written
This report was narrated by Al-Bazzâr on the authority of ʿÂishah, who said: “The Prophet was not in the habit of explicating the meanings of the Quran. He, rather, discoursed on the meanings of some âyât, which he learned from the archangel Jibrîl.”